# Hardware Software Interface

#### This is an excellent analysis of Ryan Goodfellow’s work at Oxide Computer Company, highlighting how his contributions exemplify cutting-edge hardware/software co-design. Let me analyze the key technical and strategic aspects of his approach:

## **Technical Innovation Analysis**

**1. Programmable Networking as a Foundation** Ryan’s use of P4 and Tofino 2 represents a fundamental shift from traditional fixed-function networking hardware. The ability to define packet-processing logic in software while executing it at hardware speeds (terabit line rates) is particularly significant because:

* It eliminates the CPU bottleneck that plagues software-defined networking
* Provides the flexibility of software with the performance of ASICs
* Enables rapid iteration on network protocols without hardware redesign

**2. Open Source Toolchain Strategy** The x4c compiler development is strategically brilliant because:

* It breaks vendor lock-in for P4 development
* Enables continuous integration workflows for hardware programming
* Creates a feedback loop between hardware capabilities and software innovation
* The virtual testing environment allows hardware-software co-validation without physical dependencies

## **Architectural Insights**

**3. Abstraction Layer Design** Ryan’s HAL approach addresses a critical challenge in programmable hardware:

* **Portability**: Software remains functional across hardware generations
* **Testability**: Components can be validated independently
* **Maintainability**: Updates to hardware drivers don’t break application code

**4. Rack-Scale Integration** The physical design decisions (blind-mated connections, cable-free architecture) demonstrate deep understanding of operational realities:

* Reduces human error in deployment
* Minimizes failure points
* Enables software-driven hardware discovery and management

## **Strategic Advantages**

**5. Transparency as Competitive Advantage** By open-sourcing critical components and publishing detailed documentation, Oxide gains:

* **Trust**: Customers can audit security and functionality
* **Ecosystem**: Third-party developers can extend the platform
* **Innovation**: Community contributions accelerate development
* **Talent**: Attracts engineers who value open development practices

**6. Full-Stack Ownership** The integration across firmware (openSIL), kernel (illumos drivers), hypervisor (Propolis), and hardware creates:

* **Performance optimization**: No abstraction penalties between layers
* **Security**: Complete visibility into the stack
* **Reliability**: Coordinated testing and validation across all components

## **Industry Impact**

This work represents a paradigm shift in several ways:

**Hardware Programmability Democratization**: By making P4 programming accessible through open toolchains, Ryan’s work could accelerate adoption of programmable networking beyond hyperscale companies.

**Infrastructure as Code**: The ability to define network behavior in version-controlled P4 code brings DevOps practices to hardware management.

**Security Through Transparency**: The openSIL integration and open hardware interfaces challenge the industry’s reliance on proprietary firmware and “security through obscurity.”

## **Technical Challenges Addressed**

The workflow example illustrates sophisticated engineering practices:

* Hardware-software co-simulation prevents costly integration failures
* Automated testing pipelines ensure reliability at scale
* The feedback loop from application requirements to hardware programming enables rapid feature development

This represents a mature approach to managing complexity in systems where hardware and software are equally programmable and interdependent.

Ryan’s work at Oxide demonstrates how modern infrastructure companies can differentiate through deep technical integration rather than just assembling commodity components. The emphasis on openness and transparency may well become a competitive requirement as customers demand more visibility into their infrastructure stack.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Ryan Goodfellow's work at Oxide Computer Company focuses on innovating at the hardware/software interface, particularly in the context of programmable networking and rack-scale systems. His efforts center on creating transparent, open, and efficient interfaces to bridge specialized hardware with modern software stacks. Below are the key areas and examples of his contributions:

***

## **1. Programmable Networking with P4 and Tofino 2 Switches**

Ryan leverages the **P4 language** and **Intel Tofino 2 programmable switches** to build Oxide's networking foundation. This involves:

* **Custom Data Plane Programming**: Using P4 to define packet-processing logic (e.g., routing, load balancing) directly on the Tofino 2’s programmable ASIC\[3]\[6]\[8].
* **x4c Compiler**: Oxide's open-source P4 compiler, which translates high-level P4 code into hardware-specific configurations for the Tofino 2. This toolchain enables rapid iteration and testing of network functions\[6]\[8].
* **Virtualized Testing**: Simulating Tofino 2 behavior in software to validate network protocols and hardware interactions without physical hardware. This is critical for continuous integration (CI) workflows\[6]\[8].

**Example**: Oxide’s rack-scale system uses P4 to implement a distributed routing protocol that operates at line rate (terabit speeds), avoiding CPU bottlenecks by offloading packet processing to the Tofino 2\[3]\[4].

***

## **2. Open Interfaces for Programmable Hardware**

Ryan advocates for **open standards** to democratize access to programmable hardware:

* **Open P4 ISA**: Developing an open instruction set architecture (ISA) for P4 to enable full-stack, open-source compilers. This removes reliance on proprietary toolchains and fosters ecosystem collaboration\[2]\[8].
* **openSIL Integration**: Contributing to Open-Silicon Initialization Library (openSIL), an open firmware project that replaces proprietary BIOS/UEFI code. This provides visibility into low-level hardware initialization, enabling safer and more transparent interactions\[5]\[7].
* **Kerckhoff’s Principle**: Applying the security principle of "open design" to hardware/software interfaces. For example, Oxide publishes hardware register maps and firmware source code to eliminate "security through obscurity"\[5]\[7].

***

## **3. Hypervisor and Operating System Integration**

Ryan’s work extends to integrating programmable hardware with system software:

* **illumos Kernel Drivers**: Writing drivers for Oxide’s custom hardware (e.g., NICs, switches) in the illumos kernel to expose hardware capabilities to the OS\[8]\[9].
* **Propolis Hypervisor**: Developing virtual networking interfaces in Oxide’s hypervisor to manage traffic between virtual machines and physical NICs. This includes emulating programmable NIC behavior for virtualized environments\[8]\[9].
* **Hardware Abstraction Layers (HALs)**: Creating standardized APIs to decouple software from hardware specifics. For example, Oxide’s control plane software interacts with Tofino 2 switches through a HAL, enabling portability across hardware generations\[6]\[8].

***

## **4. Rack-Scale System Design**

Oxide’s rack integrates custom hardware and software, with Ryan contributing to:

* **Unified Hardware/Software Stack**: The rack combines AMD Epyc CPUs, pooled storage/DRAM, and Tofino 2 switches into a single system. Ryan ensures these components are tightly integrated through open firmware and APIs\[4]\[6].
* **Physical Network Architecture**: Designing blind-mated, cable-free connections between compute sleds and switches to simplify maintenance and reduce failure points. This requires precise coordination between mechanical design and software auto-discovery mechanisms\[6]\[8].

***

## **5. Transparency in Hardware/Software Interfaces**

Ryan emphasizes **visibility** across the stack:

* **Open Source Tooling**: Releasing tools like x4c and contributions to openSIL under permissive licenses to foster community-driven innovation\[5]\[7]\[8].
* **Documentation Practices**: Publishing technical RFDs (Request for Discussion) that detail hardware/software interface decisions, such as Oxide’s approach to firmware updates or PCIe lane allocation\[5]\[7].

***

## **Example Workflow: Implementing a New Network Protocol**

1. **P4 Code**: Ryan writes a P4 program to define packet headers and forwarding logic.
2. **x4c Compilation**: The P4 code is compiled via x4c into a Tofino 2 configuration.
3. **Virtual Testing**: The configuration is tested in a software-emulated Tofino environment\[6]\[8].
4. **OS Integration**: illumos drivers are updated to expose new protocol features to applications.
5. **CI/CD Validation**: The entire stack is validated in Oxide’s automated testing pipeline before deployment\[8].

***

By blending open-source principles with deep hardware/software co-design, Ryan’s work at Oxide exemplifies how programmable hardware can be made accessible, efficient, and transparent—key to building next-generation cloud infrastructure.

Sources \[1] Ryan Goodfellow - Engineer - Oxide Computer Company | LinkedIn <https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryan-goodfellow-baa81053> \[2] P4 Developer Days O – P4 – Language Consortium - P4.org <https://p4.org/p4-developer-days-old/> \[3] Building a Rack-Scale Computer with P4 at the Core - InfoQ <https://www.infoq.com/presentations/tofino-2/> \[4] Startup Oxide launches on-prem cloud computing rack system <https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/startup-oxide-launches-on-prem-cloud-computing-rack-system/> \[5] Transparency in Hardware/Software Interfaces - Oxide and Friends <https://oxide-and-friends.transistor.fm/episodes/transparency-in-hardware-software-interfaces> \[6] Building a Rack Scale Computer with P4 at the Core - July 18, 2023 - Ryan Goodfellow <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnU2qVmlhvw> \[7] Oxide and Friends 2/24/2025 -- Transparency in Hardware/Software ... <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6HcBFB6wUlQ> \[8] QCon San Francisco 2023 | Building a Rack-Scale Computer with P4 at the Core: Challenges, Solutions, and Practices in Engineering Systems on Programmable Network Processors <https://qconsf.com/presentation/oct2023/building-rack-scale-computer-p4-core-challenges-solutions-and-practices> \[9] QCon San Francisco 2023 | Ryan Goodfellow <https://qconsf.com/speakers/ryangoodfellow> \[10] Transparency in Hardware/Software Interfaces | Podcast on - Spotify <https://open.spotify.com/episode/6BbAZ5rKpMZKnNCRtpgRKc> \[11] dtrace.conf(24) Ryan Goodfellow — DTrace + P4 - YouTube <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3GZQSwZyoOs> \[12] Building Big Systems with Remote Hardware Teams / Oxide <https://oxide.computer/blog/building-big-systems-with-remote-hardware-teams> \[13] Who is Oxide Computer Company? <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e2ZziEA3zPg> \[14] Investing in Oxide: Unlocking Cloud Benefits for On-prem Data ... <https://www.intelcapital.com/investing-in-oxide-unlocking-cloud-benefits-for-on-prem-data-centers/> \[15] Programming Language <https://courses.engr.illinois.edu/ece598hpn/fa2020/slides/lect10-p4.pdf>

### Connect: Join Univrs.io

* [Univrs.io Discord](https://discord.gg/pXwH6rQcsS)
* [Univrs Patreon](https://www.patreon.com/univrs)
* [Univrs.io](https://univrs.io)
* <https://ardeshir.io>
* <https://hachyderm.io/@sepahsalar>
* <https://github.com/ardeshir>
* <https://medium.com/@sepahsalar>
* <https://www.linkedin.com/in/ardeshir>
* <https://sepahsalar.substack.com/>
* [LinkTree @Sepahsalar](https://linktr.ee/Sepahsalar)
* [Univrs MetaLabel](https://univrs.metalabel.com)
